87
1. Agree with Herve's point about keeping the forum structure as simple as possible:
Quote:
Xoops is made of 5 things, the core, the module, the themes, some hacks and (no) documentation.
Suggest adding the 'suggestions' forum mentioned previously, and not having a 'complaints' forum (similar thing but think positive!)
2. I suggest NOT including the following from the O.P. because they are already handled through comments on the news stories:
* Module reviews
* Theme reviews
Alternatively, if you want to have these as forums then news stories should have comments *disabled* and include a link to direct the discussion to the relevant forum.
3. I think xoops.org needs to make up its mind whether its going to be a 'core support only' site or not. If it is, then the following forums should also be dropped:
* Module usage
* Module hacks and improvements.
Of course, if xoops.org is going to continue to be core + third party modules then it would be helpful to have a formal decision about it. There is a great deal of confusion about 'community' vs 'project', and these terms are being used in an arbitrary (and frankly, quite unhelpful) manner at the moment.
Realistically, if xoops.org has non-core forums on it then its going to continue to be a community site. I'm not saying that's a bad thing, I'm just saying that the people that are trying to pretend that its 'project only' should stop.
Thanks.