2
(that you still don't have any comments on this great site)
My first opinion it looks very good. But there is a little graphic disturbing your whole layout. That is the logo on top of the page. It doesn't fit the rest. What my solution to that is to try and fit the logo in the page.. d'oh.
How? (this is just a first idea.. I don't know how it will look like because don't have PS here and neither the time)
Align your logo to the left
On top of your menu (News-Downloads-Forums-FAQ & Help-Weblinks) color the line like the color of your logo. And remove the line from your logo itself.
Put the text from the logo (the Islanders) on the left of your menu.. so in front of News-Downloads-Forums-FAQ & Help-Weblinks.
Adjust the banner from your website to the color of your logo
Now you got your logo integrated in your site.
For the rest it look very nice.. you developed the design by your own?