2
It would be good, but I think getting to know your way around the modules is unfortunately just going to be a part of growing into Xoops. Besides, who would do the reviews, and who is to say one persons opinion of a module (which a review essentially is) should have such weight. The fallout effect from a negative review simply wouldn't be worth it in my opionion. What I DO think would be really valuable is to seperate dead projects from projects still being developed.